North East Windmills


Without government subsidies to the wind industry,
there is no wind industry.

  • Home
  • Articles
  • North East
  • Wind Problems
  • Wind Turbines
  • Wind Energy

Wind Farm Construction in the Strange World of Production Tax Credits

May 18, 2013 by Paul Crowe

This comes later, the money comes first

This heavy equipment comes later, the government money comes first

Wind energy seems to exist in a parallel universe where even simple words like “construction” no longer mean what you think they do. Why is that?

The old way

A real construction projectYou know what construction projects look like, lots of construction workers in hardhats, bulldozers and backhoes, dump trucks and dirt and when combined with hard work and sweat you get something built. That’s the way it’s done, it’s worked that way pretty much forever. Let’s call it “classic” construction.

The new way

Money for nothingIn the world of wind farms, though, there’s a new way to start a construction project, let’s call it “virtual” construction. No dirt, no sweat and certainly none of those trucks and backhoes, that’s way too much work, in fact, you could stand right in the middle of the construction and not see anything at all. Weird, huh? Welcome to the strange world of Production Tax Credits. (PTCs)

Thousands of years old and wind energy is still an infant?

Though wind developers try to hide it, without these PTC giveaways to support the “infant” wind industry, you would not see wind turbines going up anywhere. The wind industry relies on these handouts to put up turbines wherever it finds space and a community that will take them. PTCs were due, after 20 years, to finally expire December 31st, 2012, but were extended at the last minute for one more year, with one requirement to qualify for the credit, you need a working wind farm by the end of the year with turbines producing electricity. Is that too hard? Developers say it is, because when residents in a community look closely at wind turbines, they often oppose them and things slow down.

Just keep lowering the bar

Free money for wind farmsNo problem, the wizards in Washington who REALLY want to give money to wind energy, came up with something easier, instead of completing the project, you only had to start construction before the end of the year to qualify.

Well, that’s certainly less work, just dig some holes and push a little dirt around, but the wind industry thought it was still too hard. OK, how about this? You can start construction and qualify for tax credits without starting any construction at all, we’ll just redefine the word and forget the work. Easy enough now?

I.R.S. Notice 2013-29, titled, “Beginning of Construction for Purposes of the Renewable Electricity Production Tax Credit and Energy Investment Tax Credit,” explains how it works and the requirements are in sections 4 and 5, you choose either one to qualify.

Section 4 is called “Physical work.” It goes into great detail and basically says, to qualify you need a real construction project, someone gets dirty and sweaty, but why would anyone want to do that? Isn’t there an easier way? Why, yes, there is.

Section 5 is called “Safe Harbor.” Everyone’s a winner, it defines how to start and continue a construction project without building anything. Meet the requirements, get free money. Maybe now you can understand how this happened.

How do you build without building?

To show you have started construction, you must incur 5 percent of the total cost of the facility and demonstrate you are making continuous efforts. So, paying a supplier for 5 percent of the turbine parts means you’re under construction. Pretty simple.

How do you make continuous efforts?
Well there are 4 things you can do:

  • Pay more money. Why would anyone want to do that?
  • Physical work. Really? Isn’t that what we’re avoiding here?
  • Enter into binding contracts. Sounds risky, let’s not.
  • Obtain building permits. Hmm, that sounds pretty safe, OK, we’ll do that. We’re now making continuous effort, show me the money!

What if something disrupts your continuous efforts?
Hey, when the going gets tough, you know what to do, just point your finger at someone or something and you’ll still get the money.

What might slow you down?
The government lists quite a few things that might happen to hold up progress and they say none of these are your fault:

  • severe weather conditions; doesn’t apply, you’re not building anything
  • natural disasters; see above
  • labor stoppages; no construction means no labor, so no problem
  • inability to obtain specialized equipment of limited availability; see number 1
  • supply shortages; for what?, you’re not building anything
  • financing delays of less than six months; already have investors, no problem
  • delays at the written request of a state or federal agency regarding matters of safety, security, or similar concerns; this could be a real problem for most people, but this is a wind farm, so it’s not your fault, you still get the money
  • the presence of endangered species; for anyone else, this stops everything, for wind energy, you’re special, here, have some cash.
  • licensing and permitting delays; The people who are trying to go slow and do this right just don’t understand how special wind energy is, so you’re still good.
  • … but not limited to the above; Look, if you tell us you’re working hard on the project, we believe you, so you’re good to go.

You might think once you’ve passed the first step of showing you’ve started, there’s almost nothing that will prevent you from getting the tax credits, … and you might be right.

5 percent of what?

Of course, there is that one little item, you need to put up 5 percent of the cost. Is there a way to make that number smaller? Why not start telling reporters you talk to that you’ve scaled back your project from initial projections of 50 to 75 wind turbines and now it’s only going to be 10 to 20. Sure, a project that size no longer makes economic sense, but if that’s the new total number of turbines you’re telling everyone, especially if it’s 10 instead of 75, then 5 percent of that is a LOT LESS. Later, you can scale back up, but you can “start construction” and qualify for the tax credits at much lower cost. You could do that, not saying anyone would, but it’s certainly possible.

So work hard to get the wind ordinance in place and then qualify for tax credits. After that, it’s easy money, but hurry, offer ends December 31st, 2013.

It almost makes a person think the government is giving wind developers special treatment that no other businesses can get. Hmm, … would they do that?

Filed Under: Wind Energy Disadvantages Tagged With: PTC, tax credit, taxpayers

What can you do?

  • Be informed! Read as many articles on this website as you have time for, so you can understand the issue. Do your own research. Check us out.
  • Tell your neighbors about the wind turbines, point them to this website so they can learn more.

Unfortunately

The less you know about wind energy,
the more you'll like it.

Why wind developers never understand …

It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it.

~ Upton Sinclair

Don’t know – Don’t care

Is willful ignorance necessary
to promote wind energy?

No, but it helps.

Climate Change

Another thing I must point out is that you cannot prove a vague theory wrong. … Also, if the process of computing the consequences is indefinite, then with a little skill any experimental results can be made to look like the expected consequences.

~ Richard Feynman, 1964

It’s not on-demand, it’s no-demand

Wind energy is "no-demand" electricity. If the wind isn't blowing and you demand electricity, the answer is no.

Wind – expensive, inefficient, unreliable



December 1923 Popular Science cover dreaming about generating electricity from windmills, and though the dream never dies, the dream doesn't work, didn't then, doesn't now and without huge government giveaways of your money, no wind farms would get built anywhere. The government forces utilities to buy wind power so payments to landowners are simply wind welfare.


Wind energy runs on tax credits

"I will do anything that is basically covered by the law to reduce Berkshire's tax rate, for example, on wind energy, we get a tax credit if we build a lot of wind farms. That's the only reason to build them. They don't make sense without the tax credit."
~ Warren Buffett - from interview with Fortune magazine

Wind investments and high cost green energy

“I’m in the wind business … I’ve lost my ass in the business. ... Hey, we can get on everything green. We can get on everything renewable. Then the cost of power will go up ten times."
~ T. Boone Pickens - on Morning Joe on MSNBC

Wind Turbine Map

Information you'll only see here.

The complete map of all of the wind turbines proposed by Pioneer Green Energy in Erie County, PA and filed with the FAA. Plans not yet filed are not shown.

Recent Comments

  • Susan Dudley on Omnibus Spending Bill Extends Wind Energy PTC for 5 Years with Phaseout Over Last 3 Years
  • Jack Christman a on Omnibus Spending Bill Extends Wind Energy PTC for 5 Years with Phaseout Over Last 3 Years
  • Suzanne Albright on Omnibus Spending Bill Extends Wind Energy PTC for 5 Years with Phaseout Over Last 3 Years
  • Chris on Pioneer Green Energy Quits Wind Project in North East, PA
  • Tammy C. Truitt on Pioneer Green Energy Quits Wind Project in North East, PA
  • Shannon Mackey on Pioneer Green Energy Quits Wind Project in North East, PA
  • Tammy C. Truitt on Defense Department Rebuffs Pioneer Green Energy in Maryland

North East Windmills

  • Vestas Shares Sink with Donald Trump’s Election Win
  • Supreme Court Halts Enforcement of Clean Power Plan
  • Omnibus Spending Bill Extends Wind Energy PTC for 5 Years with Phaseout Over Last 3 Years
  • Pioneer Green Energy Quits Wind Project in North East, PA
  • Defense Department Rebuffs Pioneer Green Energy in Maryland

RSS North East PA Online

  • North East Borough Holding Public Hearing on North East Comprehensive Plan
  • North East School District Seeking Bids for Pool Liner Installation
  • North East School District Requests Bids for E-Rate Eligible Internet and Phone Services
  • Greenfield Township Boards and Commissions 2023 Schedule
  • North East Township Water and Sewer Rates Rising to Reflect Increased Costs

RSS Erie County Report

  • Senator Doug Mastriano Restore Freedom Rally – Erie Bayfront October 14th
  • Remember This Photo From the Erie Airport? Did You Ever See It?
  • Here’s a Quick Way to Increase Your Resistance to COVID-19
  • Test What Works Before Building a Community College
  • How Many College Students are Hospitalized From COVID-19? – Zero?
  • Dangerous and Safe Gatherings Due to COVID-19 – a Helpful Guide

Copyright © 2023 · North East Windmills · Website by Crowe Computer Services
This website proudly Made in the USA!
Made in the USA